While reflecting upon his time at OSU, alumnus John Heinl ‘82 shared to the Ohio State University Monthly that “my education involved more than classrooms and studying, it included traditions…”1 These traditions entailed memories made on High Street, just as much as the ones made in classrooms and the ‘Shoe. Whether it be providing student employment, memorable meals, football celebrations, and life-long relationships, High Street has truly been a staple of student life, and this three-part series will explore its importance, starting South and working its way North.
Voted both the best and worst “bar to get sick in” from a 1988 Lantern poll, Papa Joe’s was a bar particularly beloved for its bucket deals, the “‘suction’ sound of walking across the beer-soaked floor,” and its kegs and eggs tailgates.2 The place was even nationally renowned, with a Florida radio station calling in at 6:30 a.m. on a 1990s game day to hear students sing the fight song.3
Along with Papa Joe’s, OSU students flocked South to frequent Mean Mr. Mustard’s, Oar House, South Berg, and the Bier Stube for all Buckeye celebrations (and current Buckeyes and visiting alumni will soon be able to visit the Bier Stube after its reopening in a new location).
Prior to being known for the Clothing Underground’s selection of “Jesus Hates Michigan” shirts, the 1898 N. High Street location used to house the State Restaurant and, later, Columbus’s “counter-culture headquarters for three decades.”4 Between the late 1950s to 1970s, the State Restaurant was remembered by Jeff Yungman ‘73 as “an oasis of home cooking on High Street” and was beloved by law students.5 As alumnus Mike Sproule ‘71, ‘71 MA, ‘73 PhD put it best: “Who would want to miss those spareribs, short ribs, and homemade pies!”6
The gift shop Trade Winds took up the torch of fostering community as its “employees and regulars nurtured the Community Festival from a campus street fair to the annual three-day blowout in Goodale Park” until its closure in 2000.7 Additionally, its owner, Libby Gregory, “edited the Columbus Free Press upstairs.”8
(This is a three-part series, written by Archives student assistant Fran McConnell.)
1 “High Street reshuffled.” Ohio State University Monthly. 2009 May, pp. 26.
2 “Presenting the best and worst of Ohio State.” The Lantern, 1 December 1988; Fiely, Dennis. “Check it off the list.” Ohio State University Monthly, June 2019, pp. 61.
3 Fodor, Sharon. “New home for Papa Joe’s still unknown.” The Lantern, Volume 16, Number 173, 6 December 1996.
4 Lalonde, Brent. “The High Street Shuffle.” Ohio State University Monthly. 2009 January, pp. 9.
5 “High Street reshuffled,” pp. 24.
6 “High Street reshuffled,” pp. 21.
7 Lalonde. “The High Street Shuffle,” pp. 9.
8 Lalonde. “The High Street Shuffle,” pp. 9.









Recent Comments