The Robert Butche Papers contain files from Butche's school days at University School, booklets from the school, and a copy of his book, Growing Up in University School.

The Robert Meiklejohn Diplomas contain two diplomas belonging to Robert Meiklejohn: a Chillicothe High School diploma awarded May 31, 1900, and an Ohio State University diploma in Mechanical Engineering awarded June 22, 1904.

The James Weaver Scrapbook is a scrapbook from part of Weaver's time as a student at University School; it covers the years 1953 through 1957.