From the heights of Brasília…

 

 

 

The Kubitschek Presidency, a Half-Century On:

Five Phases of Assessment in Fifty Years since

the Inauguration of JK (1956-2006)

 

 

 

Edward A. Riedinger

Visiting Research Associate
Michaelmas Term, 2006

 

Click for larger image

 

Centre for Brazilian Studies, Oxford University

14 November 2006

 

 

 

 

 

 

Abstract

 

This essay reviews five phases in the assessment of the presidency of Juscelino Kubitschek since his inauguration half a century ago in 1956.  The introduction explains the relationship of the author as secretary for English correspondence to Dr. Kubitschek from 1972 to 1976.  The next parts trace the 50-year period in terms of: 1) Rise and fall, 1956-1964; 2) exile and hope, 1964-1976; 3) recognition, 1976-1985; and 4) apotheosis, 1985-2006.  The fifth and final part (2006 on) provides a profile of the research needs and resources for developing a phase of concentrated scholarship on Juscelino Kubitschek and the Brazilian presidency.  Such a focus of research is urged based on the exceptional character of the Kubitschek presidency in relation to the other periods in the history of the Brazilian republic.

 

All images reproduced here are exclusively for educational purposes.  Citation of any source does not imply support for or agreement with the same.

Copyright © of text only Edward Anthony Riedinger 2006

 

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 

 

Introduction

 

1.  My Role with Juscelino Kubitschek

I first met and began to work with Dr. Kubitschek in February, 1972, doing so until June, 1976, just before he died.  I usually met with him twice a week and helped him with translations, composition of letters or other documents in English, and conversed with him so that he could maintain some basic fluency in the language.  During my last two years with him, I kept a record of our conversations as a collection of interviews.  Although he was fluent in French, he only began to learn English after he became president, having a British tutor at the Catete.  Preceding me as his secretary/tutor was the Canadian poet, Edward Lacey. 

 

During the period I worked for him, I was preparing my doctoral dissertation for the History Department at the University of Chicago.  In a letter to that department, he authorized me to write my dissertation on any phase of his presidency.  I wrote on his election campaign of 1954-1955, a work which was later published as Como se faz um presidente:  A campanha de JK (Nova Fronteira, 1988).

 

What most struck me, or anyone else, about him was his confidence and optimism.  Nonetheless, he was a very serious person.  Although his public rhetoric was to make things simple, direct, and positive, he very much appreciated subtle, complex thought.  He was not himself an original thinker; but he was surrounded, and absorbingly admired, by a generation of some of the most outstanding literary, cultural, and intellectual figures in Brazilian history.  It has been said that in the second half of the twentieth century, the Brazilian Academy of Letters sounded like him because half its members had written for him.  His personality was quite singular:  energetic, positive, ambitious, vastly curious (somewhat impressionable), invariably cordial and affable but also abrupt.

 

 

 

2.  His Role with Others at the Time I Worked with Him

There was a small "court-in-exile" that consisted of:

- His office secretary at Banco DENASA and Manchete, Dona Elizabeth.

- His chauffer and "quebra-galho," Geraldo (who died in the auto accident on the Via Dutra with him).

- Secretary/tutor for French, Geraldo França de Lima, a mineiro novelist, who had known George Bernanos (Journal d'un curé de campagne) who lived in exile in Brazil from 1938 to 1945.

- Secretary/tutor for English, myself.

- His wife, Dona Sara; and two daughters: Marcia, Maria Estela, who were occasionally present.  I watched the TV announcement, with him and Da. Sara, of Ernesto Geisel as president

- Head of Manchete and casual publicity/political adviser, Adolfo Bloch ("urso branco")

 

How he dealt with these people suggested how he may have done so with the staff (ministers, advisers, patrons, etc.) of his government aides:  If you knew something, you were consulted, an ‘’authority.”  He would be effusively grateful yet could also be demanding and immediate. 

 

3.  The Dynamics of His Formation

These personal and intellectual qualities underlay the boldness and style with which he acted politically and socially.  This boldness, however, must partially have been rooted in the confidence he acquired by 1) overcoming his childhood of poverty, 2) being sustained by the devotion of his mother, and 3) accumulating the experience of his work-intensive youth.  These factors obtain, of course, beyond or in addition to whatever comes with alpha plus male genes.  Bold and confident, he knew it was he who could enact, that he would fulfill, the vanguard ideas and creations presented to him.  He would mark his passage in history by wedding the substance of economic development with the style of international high modernism, generously lubricated with affable politics.  (His tomb in Brasilía is marked “The Founder.”  As president he could well be designated “The Enactor.”)

 

The name “Kubitschek” was somewhat prominent in late nineteenth century Minas politics due to his maternal great uncle, João Nepomuceno Kubitschek.  Elected to the state constituent assembly after the declaration of the Republic, he became vice-presidente (ie, lieutenant governor) of Minas Gerias from 1894 to 1898.  During this period the transfer of the state’s capital from Ouro Preto to the newly-planned Belo Horizonte occurred.  For some reason Juscelino’s mother was alienated from her relatives, possibly because of her marriage to a bohemian figure – of whom Juscelino was very proud – but who died when the boy and his sister were very young. 1

 

Juscelino knew he belonged and could aspire to a higher socio-economic status.  By studying at a seminary at reduced tuition, working as a telegraph operator to go through medical school, going on for advanced surgical specialization in Paris, marrying socially upward, and establishing himself as a very successful surgeon, he proved overwhelmingly to himself and others the socio-economic status to which he had a right.  He secured a sequence political positions that consolidated and acknowledged it.

 

●_________ One

1.  Rise and Fall

1956-1964

 

His presidency was exceptional.  The regime that followed him had no tolerance for exceptions. 

 

At the heart of the campaign of 1954-55 and the presidency of 1956-61 was this extremely confident and energetic personality, resolutely assertive, rarely abrasive, and always conciliatory.  He is somewhat the FDR figure of Brazilian history -- or FDR is somewhat the JK figure of the US presidency conducted in a less global context.  Juscelino's presidential theme song could as much have been Happy Days as Peixe Vivo.  In 1961 the plans were already in place for his re-election campaign for 1964-1965. 2

 

 

His presidency was economically and politically successful based on a very delicate and rare balance in Brazilian history.  On the one hand, the dominant Third World, non-communist ideology was development through industrialization.  In the decade after the end of WWII, surplus capital for investment had once again begun to accrue in the fortifying economies of Germany, Britain, France, and Italy.  Moreover, this reserve joined the vast bulk of American capital for overseas investment.  Concentrating on industrial development and welcoming foreign capital, Juscelino did not have to suffer so much of the earlier initial opposition to foreign economic control—which Vargas had exhausted, and exploited as much for policy priorities as political ones.  Indeed, Juscelino was surrounded by quite a cadre of very respected "desenvolimentista" intellectuals and economists.  Much of the purpose of the metas policy was to say “this is what my government can produce and what you will share in -- there is something for everybody."  His confidence and energy sealed this promise to the public. 3

 

Furthermore, as the fruits of economic development emerged (the buying power of the minimum wage increased--but would erode with inflation), social pressures for political extremes were somewhat mitigated.  However, Juscelino in no way had an unchallengeable political base.  His assets were considerable but had to be continually nurtured.  At the core of his support was the PSD of Minas Gerais and steady popular support.  He had some penetration in the PTB and connections in the PR and even UDN.  He had mutual assurances with communists and solid relations with most of the Catholic hierarchy, especially the bishops of the Northeast.  He had constantly to negotiate and conciliate the political environment, at which he was quite good.  Thereby a real equilibrium of legislative/executive checks-and-balances operated. 

 

 

"To keep his campaign promises in spite of all his political and economic harassments will be a racking task even for a President with Juscelino Kubitschek's energy. But he seems confident that he can deliver, just as he did in Minas Gerais. "I take office," he said last week, "with a serene conviction that I can and will be a good President for my country." 4

 

The "anos dourados" of JK were essentially a conjuncture of events in which targeted increases of foreign capital investment produced a widening distribution of industrial, multiplier-effect economic goods within a government environment of open, give-and-take politics, mirrored in a cultural environment of great originality and vibrancy.  The smiles, abraços, and bossa echoed that.  During those years more than two billion dollars of US, European (especially German), and Japanese capital entered the country, mostly for the “metas” projects.   In today’s values, this would at least be 25 billion dollars.  However, Brazil lost capital in terms of exports due to the world coffee over supply and the US opposition to Brazil opening the Soviet Union and eastern Europe as markets.  Moreover, the drought in the Northeast was a drain on federal and state coffers.

 

However, what brought the golden years together also unraveled them.  Accelerated rates of development that required deficit spending beyond outside capital investment provoked inflation with factors of demand pushing prices up and supply pulling them up.  Eroding thereby the rising expectations of social benefits, this deterioration fed political animosities, particularly based on perceptions of unfair, corrupt distribution of retracting resources. 5

 

Definitely Juscelino intended to return to the presidency in 1965 (his announcement of his candidacy in March, 1964 was one of the elements that fed into the coup begun on the 31st of that month).  From records I last saw at his office (about 1977) in Manchete, but which may now be in the JK mausoleum (where the furniture from that office is now on display), he intended to base a good part of his next government on export agriculture.  With his own presidential ambitions for 1965, his strategy may have little interest in a PSD candidate winning the presidency in 1960.  Such a person would diminish Jusceliono’s party leadership during his next campaign.  Moreover, by this time, he had a decade of national experience with the PTB.  He knew both the advantages of an alliance with it and populists and also the disadvantages.  There was an essential policy alienation from such and alliance with consequent unreliability.  He had probably gained as much political penetration in that direction as he would ever have or could risk. 

 

Most advantageous for him actually was for Juraci Magalhães and the UDN to come to power.  Magalhães was in the UDN as a kind of para-PSD.  He had been and interventor and governor in Bahia before the Estado Novo, at which time he left office and returned to the army, where he eventually became a reserve general.  It was in this capacity that he supported Eduardo Gomes and the UDN in 1945.  Juscelino knew that Juraci would keep a stable government, allowing him to run again.  Moreover, Juraci was not dynamic.  Stagnation would make Juscelino look even better—especially with an export agricultural policy for the Northeast, for which it would be necessary to have some kind of accommodation with the UDN in order to enact basic land reform.  Juscelino wanted what Jânio kept bungling around for:  a populist center right spectrum of support. 6

 

 

 

Juscelino’s meeting with JFK at the White House in January, 1961, may well have been prompted by Juscelino's plans for re-election in 1965.  Anticipating that Kennedy would be a two-term president (1961-1969) and that he himself would be returning to Brasília in 1966, he would have hoped that a strong relationship with a liberal Democrat would be much more helpful than the frustrating one he had with Eisenhower and Dulles. 

 

Message to President Kubitschek of Brazil. 7

January 31st, 1961

[ Released January 31, 1961 Dated January 29, 1961 ]

Dear Mr. President:

I welcome the thoughtful message which you sent to me on the occasion of my inauguration, not only because of the constructive and friendly spirit which motivates your comments, but also because I share Your Excellency's deep concern for the social, political, and economic well-being of the peoples of our hemisphere. One of the cardinal objectives of my administration will be the association of the United States with the peoples of Latin America in a common effort to improve the lives of our peoples under the reign of liberty.

May I take this opportunity, Mr. President, to extend to you, as you leave the high office in which you have so faithfully served your country, my personal best wishes and those of the people and government of the United States of America, for your continued health and prosperity.
Sincerely,

JOHN F. KENNEDY

 

The politics of Juscelino’s foreign relations, especially in Latin America, were quite original.  It was he who persuaded the US to support the Interamerican Development Bank and a “common market of the Americas.”  He invited Adolfo López Mateos of Mexico and Fidel Castro of Cuba to Brazil.  He was the first Brazilian president to visit several of the Andean countries.  He attempted to have Brazil invest in petroleum exploration in Bolivia.

 

However, Jânio substituting Jângo resulted in the worst case scenario for any hope of an environment of stability and advantageous foiling that could foster Juscelino’s return.  Indeed, the economic and political situation spinning totally out of control in the 39 months from January, 1961 to March, 1964, Juscelino was permanently marginalized from any future political role. 8

 

●_________ Two

 

2.  Exile and Hope

1964-1976

 

--Cassação, exile (Portugal, France, US), Frente Ampla, June 1966 to April 1968

--Return to private business, Banco DENASA de Investimentos

--Publication of memoirs

Meu caminho para Brasília:   v. 1. A experiência da humildade.--v. 2. A escalada política.--v. 3. Cinqüenta anos em cinco 1974-

Por que construí Brasília, 1975

--Election to Mineira Academy of Letters, 1974 (letter of congratulations from Sen. Ted Kennedy).  Lost election to Academia Brasileira de Letras to Bernardo Elis. 1975.

--MDB Elections of 1974 and Geisel distensão. 9

Porcentagem de Cadeiras na Câmara dos Deputados, por Partido (1966-1978)

PARTIDO

1966

1970

1974

1978

ARENA

67.7

71.9

55.8

55.0

MDB

32.3

28.1

44.2

45.0

Total (=100)

409

310

364

420

 

  Juca Pato award for Intelectual do Ano from the União Brasileira de Escritores, in São Paulo, 1975

 Vítima de tanto levar na cabeça, Juca Pato tinha que conformar-se, pois sempre "podia ser pior" 10

 

  End of DENASA, 1975

 


Working in office at Banco DENASA

 

  Maria Victória Benevides book, O governo Kubitschek, 1976 11

  See context of other publications, p. 20.

 

Via Dutra on the way to Luziana, Goias, 1976

 

 

 

Car accident on Via Dutra (near Resende), Sunday, 22 August 1976

 

“E estava justamente em Luziânia quando, a 7 de agosto de 1976, os repórteres o procuraram para saber se era mesmo boato a notícia de que ele morrera na Via Dutra. "Estão querendo me matar, mas ainda não conseguiram", comentou com amigos. No dia 22 de agosto de 1976, JK morreu num acidente de carro, exatamente na Via Dutra. O Opala do presidente, guiado pelo motorista Geraldo Ribeiro, seguia de São Paulo para o Rio de Janeiro quando foi atingido por um ônibus, passou para a outra pista e bateu de frente num caminhão carregado de gesso.


Não faltam teses conspiratórias para explicar o que o inquérito policial apontou como simples desastre. Há quem diga que havia explosivos no automóvel. Outros apostam que um tiro disparado por ocupantes de um veículo não-identificado acertou o motorista Geraldo, que perdeu o controle do Opala. "A versão oficial é uma grande montagem", acusa o perito criminal Alberto Carlos de Minas. Em 1996, ele foi um dos responsáveis pela reabertura do caso. As investigações não avançaram e o inquérito, após 20 anos, acabou prescrevendo. No entanto, Alberto Carlos e Serafim Jardim - presidente da Casa de Juscelino em Diamantina - ainda hoje se dizem convictos de que JK foi morto por ordem dos militares no poder.


Os indícios são muitos, de acordo com a tese conspiratória. Em agosto de 1976, o diretor do serviço secreto chileno, Manuel Contreras Sepúlveda, enviou carta ao general João Baptista Figueiredo, então chefe do Serviço Nacional de Informações, dizendo-se preocupado com o possível triunfo do Partido Democrata nas eleições americanas. "Temos conhecimento do reiterado apoio dos democratas a Kubitschek e Letelier." Orlando Letelier, ministro do presidente chileno deposto, Salvador Allende, morreria num atentado em Washington, pouco antes da morte de JK. As fotos dos cadáveres de JK e do motorista simplesmente não foram anexadas ao inquérito. O caixão com o corpo do motorista foi lacrado, sem que se pudesse checar se ele levou um tiro na cabeça, como especulam os juscelinistas. Em 1996, o corpo foi exumado. "Pode ter sido imaginação minha, já que estava eufórico demais. Mas vi um orifício no crânio de Geraldo. Dias depois, os legistas responsáveis pelo laudo avisaram que o crânio se fragmentara, algo incomum com o manuseio de profissionais", afirma o perito Alberto Carlos de Minas. O mistério contribui ainda mais para perpetuar o mito Juscelino Kubitschek.”
12

Note:  Remembering the role of Nixon and Kissinger in the overthrow and death of Allende, the above (paragraph 3) has a particularly chilling reverberation.

General Juan Manuel Guillermo Contreras Sepúlveda was the head of Augusto Pinochet's National Intelligence Directorate (DINA) and one of the most powerful and feared men in Chile after a military coup overthrew Socialist President Salvador Allende on September 11, 1973. Documents released by the CIA in 2000 revealed that Contreras was a CIA paid asset from 1975 to 1977.

From 1973 to 1977, he led the agency on an international hunt to track down and murder the political opponents of the dictatorship, particularly members of the Communist and Socialist Parties and the Movement of the Revolutionary Left (MIR). According to the report "CIA activities in Chile" released on September 19, 2000, the US government policy community approved CIA's contact with Contreras from 1974 to 1977 to accomplish the CIA's mission in Chile. 13

●_________ Three

 

3.  Recognition (Remembering a Hope)

1976-1985

  Funeral,1976

 

     

 

Mass funeral cortege, Brasília

 

“Roberto Marinho pede que JK tome cuidado com os militares. JK sofre um atentado, mas consegue escapar ileso. JK compra uma fazenda e vai morar lá, mas esse não é o seu estilo de vida. Corre a notícia de que JK morreu, mas ele reúne a imprensa para desmentir o boato. Duas semanas depois, JK e seu motorista, Geraldo Ribeiro, morrem num acidente de carro; os dois são velados lado a lado no saguão do prédio da Manchete. Arrasada, Sarah recebe os pêsames de amigos e familiares. O povo homenageia JK cantando “Peixe vivo” diante de seu caixão. Marisa chora copiosamente ao presenciar tudo aquilo. A pensão de Guiomar progride e vira hotel. O povo se aglomera no aeroporto para receber o corpo de JK. Uma multidão forma o cortejo em homenagem a JK nas ruas, com faixas, cartazes e lágrimas. Na missa de corpo presente, na Catedral de Brasília, Ana e Sérgio se reconciliam. Numa igreja do Rio de Janeiro, Marisa sofre terrivelmente pela morte de JK. Com a permissão de Sarah, o povo carrega o caixão de JK. O caixão segue num carro do Corpo de Bombeiros até o cemitério. No cortejo, Silvinha e Leonardo se reconciliam. Lílian e Alzira fazem as pazes durante o enterro. Sarah fica com a bandeira que cobria o caixão e dá seu último adeus ao marido.” 14

 

  Birthplace Museum in Diamantina, 197?  Casa de Juscelino Kubitschek

Esta é uma casa modesta, construída de pau-a-pique, típica do século XVIII. Lá o ex-presidente da República Juscelino Kubistschek passou sua infância.

Após sua morte a casa foi transformada em um museu que expõe fotografias, textos e até violões usados nas serestas que ele participava.

 

 

 Sílvio Tendler Documentary, Os anos JK, uma trajetória política, 1980 15

 

 

  Mausoleum, 1981

 

                                   

The Memorial JK was formally opened by Da. Sara and Pres. João Figueiredo on 12 September 1981 (the 79th birthday of Juscelino). 

 

 Tancredo Neves Campaign, 1985         

 

“In 1984 many public demonstrations were held in main Brazilian cities making clear that military rule could not continue. Brazilians started to demand changes in the electoral system, aiming to directly elect the President. As public pressure built up, the opposition party (MDB) proposed a law to implement this change. Congress was controlled by the government party (ARENA) and failed to pass the law.

The momentum though was seized by Tancredo Neves of Minas Gerais, Getúlio Dornelles Vargas' minister of justice in the 1950s, and former federal deputy, senator, and prime minister. [Cabo eleitoral of JK in 1954-55). Neves was a sensible politician with a reputation for honesty.

His abilities allowed him to build up an alliance between the opposition party (MDB) and defectors from the government party (ARENA): The Democratic Alliance (Aliança Democrática) presented itself tuned with 1984's demands for political change and end of military rule.

It presented Tancredo Neves as opposition candidate against Paulo Maluf in the Electoral College. As public opinion put pressure on Electoral College demanding the end of the regime, Tancredo was elected my majority vote in January 15, 1985.” 16

The presidential campaign of Tancredo Neves was based on the principle that the return to a civilian, democratic government depended on a senior statesman of the moderate opposition, committed to national reconciliation.  This had been the hope of Juscelino for his own “last hurrah.”

 

 

●_________ Four

 

4.  Apotheosis (Into the National Pantheon)

1985-2006

  Currency, 1986

 

 

 

 

 Como se faz um presidente:  A campanha de JK, 1988

 

 

 

The publishing of this book reflected the key importance in the mid-eighties that the election of Juscelino had assumed as a marker of successful civilian government.  The proposal for its publication came from the political adviser Wellington Moreira Franco, governor of the state of Rio de Janeiro, who had presidential ambitions.  He was at the time married to the daughter of Ernani do Amaral Peixoto, who had been one of he key political supporters of Juscelino.  The publisher, Editora Nova Fronteira, was headed by the two sons of Carlos Lacerda, who welcomed the work in the publishing list.  It represented their identification with the return to direct, civilian presidential elections and democratic government in Brazil

 

"Orestes Quércia e Fernando Collor de Mello também se apresentaram ao eleitorado como herdeiros de JK. Quércia abraçou a imagem de tocador de obra, enquanto Collor quis ser um ícone da modernidade. Collor não tem o bom humor de JK. Pelo contrário, ele tem um fígado shakespeariano." 17

 

 Isto É Man-of-Century, 2000

 

1) Juscelino Kubitschek

 

 

 

 G Globo Novela, 2006 18

 

 

 

●_________ Five

 

5.  Getting Serious and Studious: 

2006-forward

 

  Why is such study important?

Posterior to key presidents and their presidencies, a succession of popular and scholary studies accumulates:  Franklin D. Roosevelt, Domingo Sarmiento, Bartolomé Mitre

 

  Recognizing his distinction by what he was:

--Establishing a model for a Brazilian presidency:  socio-economic achievement, political vibrance, cultural character/definition/projection, and engagement of a national spirit.

--Holistic, integrated developmentalist vision and conscientious synergistic actions across economic, political, diplomatic, and cultural spectrum.

--Without JK and Brasília, the renaissance in the tropics would not have had such an extended character.  It would have subsided with the Generation of '45, concretism, and bossa nova.  Brasilia revived the modernism of 1922 in architecture, landscape and interior design, and sculpture, transforming Brazil into a focus of international modernism with a dynamic tropical style and accent.

 

  Recognizing him by what he was not:

--Not a type of:  patriarch of a plantation empire or republic (Pedro II, Campos Salles, Rodrigues Alves, Arthur Bernardes; "caudilho" (Getulio) or "jagunço" corporate president (Costa e Silva, Medici, Geisel, Figueiredo); certainly not a species of jaded playboy (Collor), Graucho Marx (Itamar), or strong technocrat but relatively limp politician (FHC)

 

  What has been done:

--Presidency and Historical Context of Presidency

Brasil política, 1964-1975, F. Pereira, 1975; Brasil de Getúlio Vargas a Castello Branco, T. Skidmore, 1976; O governo Kubitschek, M. V. Benevides, 1975; Estado e partidos políticos no Brasil, 1939-1964, M. C. Campello de Souza, 1976; A bancada federal mineira, 1945-1975, D. V. Fleischer, 1977; O governo Kubitschek, R. Maranhão, 1981; Ideologia da cultura brasileira, 1933-1974, C. Mota, 1985.

Unrest in Brazil, 1955-1964, J. Dulles, 1970; Brazil, a study in development progress, S. Robock, 1975; The revolution that never was:  Northeast Brazil, 1955-1964, J. Page, 1972.

 

  What Is to be done:

--Biography and/or Separate Monographs

--psycho-social/family dynamics

--a generation of mineiro politicians

--the Brazilian standard and exceptionality as a politician

--interaction with intellectuals and artists

--economic policy and practice

--public policy and parallel state agencies

--the profit in construction (roads, buildings – Pampulha, Brasília), in land being turned into real estate

--originality of hemispheric policy

 

  What documentation is where (some possible leads to sources, not definitive listing)

--Public Documents

   Primay

-- Centro de Pesquisa e Documentação de História Contemporânea do Brasil (CPDOC) of the Fundação Getúlio Vargas -- Rio (as much for materials as staff connections to sources)  http://www.cpdoc.fgv.br/nav_jk/htm/apresentacao/apresentacao.asp

--JK Mausoleum library and museum -- Brasília  (as much for materials as staff connections to sources) http://www.memorialjk.com.br/

   Secondary

--Arquivo Nacional -- Rio

--Museu da República -- Rio

--Federal police files – Rio, Brasília

--Academia Mineira de Letras – Belo Horizonte

--Arquivo Público Mineiro, Arquivo Público da Cidade de Belo Horizonte

--Private Sources

--Manchete, family of Adolpho Bloch, Carlos Heitor Cony, Dona Elizabeth (former secretary)

--Ma. Estela, surviving daughter

--Marcia, deceased; second husband, Fernando Bujones (Cuban ballet dancer); first husband, Bartolomeu Barbará, investment banker; JK grandaughter, Alejandra Kubitschek Bujones

 

 

myth and reality

 

There is a sense in which Juscelino’s life can almost be read as an epic tale: 

 

 

Once upon a time there was a poor boy from the interior of Brazil.  By dint of hard work and native wit, he rose in life, vindicating his family position.  Skilled as a healer, he married a society princess.  By appointment and popular acclaim he ascended to ever higher positions of leadership.  Finally he became head of the realm.  He presided over a court of noted advisers and skilled artisans.  He led his people to a new land and era. 

 

However, leaving office, armed forces of oppression detained and exiled him, taking over the realm.  They allowed him to return to the country, but required him to live in obscurity.  On a fateful journey, accompanied by a faithful courtier, he died in a tragic accident.  Rumors of assassination circulated.  Now the armed forces of oppression collapse.  The outrages they were committing proved worse than any of which they had accused him. 

 

The people now freely remembered his spirit, deeds, and glory.  They and the government enshrined him among the nation’s highest symbols and elevate him into the pantheon of guiding national heroes.

 

 

 

 

O peixe viveu.

 

1902-1976

ReFERENCES

 

1  Kubitschek, Juscelino, A experiência da humildade, vol. 1 in Meu caminho para Brasília; Montello, J., A oratório atual do Brasil, 1959.

 

2  http://www.cpdoc.fgv.br/, 1 November 2006, see section, "Os anos JK."

 

3  Kubitschek, Juscelino, Meu caminho…; Thomas E. Skidmore, Politics in Brazil, 1930-1964; an experiment in democracy, 1967.

 

4  "The Man from Minas" (cover story), Time, 14 February 1956.

 

5  Kahil, R., Inflation and economic development in Brazil, 1973; Skidmore, Thomas E., The politics of military rule in Brazil, 1964-85, 1988.

 

6  Kubitischek, Juscelino, Interviews with Juscelino Kubitschek de Oliveira, (President of Brazil, 1956-1961) / conducted by Edward A. Riedinger, 1974-1975.

7 
From “The American Presidency Project “ at the University of California, Santa Barbara, http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/print.php?pid=8067, 6 November 2006

 

8  Kubitischek, Juscelino, Interviews with....; Skidmore, Thomas, The politics of military rule in Brazil, 1964-85, 1988.

 

9  http://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/PMDB, 4 November 2006; http://www.fugpmdb.org.br/do_mdb_ao_pmdb.pdf, 4 November 2006 includes a list of all MDB members of Congress during the seventies.

 

10  For details of award, see http://www.concursosliterarios.com.br/materias.php?cd_secao=7&codant=, 7 November 2006.

11  A flurry of titles, in Portuguese and English, on the Kubitschek presidency and its historical context appeared during the seventies:  

Portuguese:  Brasil política, 1964-1975, F. Pereira, 1975; Brasil de Getúlio Vargas a Castello Branco, T. Skidmore, 1976; O governo Kubitschek, M. V. Benevides, 1975 (see further at end of this note); Estado e partidos políticos no Brasil, 1939-1964, M. C. Campello de Souza, 1976; A bancada federal mineira, 1945-1975, D. V. Fleischer, 1977; O governo Kubitschek, R. Maranhão, 1981; Ideologia da cultura brasileira, 1933-1974, C. Mota, 1985.
English:  Unrest in Brazil, 1955-1964, J. Dulles, 1970; Brazil, a study in development progress, S. Robock, 1975; The revolution that never was:  Northeast Brazil, 1955-1964, J. Page, 1972.

"A estabilidade do governo de Juscelino Kubitschek era aparente ou verdadeira? Em busca desta resposta, Maria Victoria Benevides mostra como a política econômica - cujo o núcleo básico era o Programa de Metas, compromisso de campanha do presidente eleito - se tornou compatível tanto com as Forças Armadas como com o Congresso Nacional, palco de aliança majoritária entre PSD e PTB. Atrelado ao desenvolvimento econômico, ocorre também um desenvolvimento político, fruto da postura conciliadora do presidente. Manter a estabilidade política não se deveu somente ao desempenho de Juscelino, mas também devido a intervenção militar do general Lott na manutenção da ordem para assegurar o desenvolvimento econômico, mesma postura que os militares no poder, após 1964, utilizaram para dominar a cena política brasileira por mais de 30 anos." -- Patrício Bentes at http://afiliados.submarino.com.br/books_productdetails.asp?Query=ProductPage&ProdTypeId=1&ProdId=31637&ST=SE#synopsys


12 
Isto é, http://www.terra.com.br/istoe/biblioteca/brasileiro/seculo/indice.htm, 12 November 2006

 

13  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manuel_Contreras, 4 November 2006

 

14 TV Globo blurb for miniseries, JK, chapter "Missão Cumprida"  http://jk.globo.com/Series/JK/0,,AA1164666-5072,00.html, 5 November 2005

 

15  For list and description of other documentaries of Sílvio Tendler, see http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0854913/, 30 October 2006

 

16  http://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tancredo_Neves, 8 November 2006 and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tancredo_Neves, 8 November 2006

 

17  Bolívar Lamounier (Da independência a Lula:  Dois séculos de política brasileira, 2005) as quoted in http://www.terra.com.br/istoe/biblioteca/brasileiro/seculo/indice.htm, 12 November 2006

 

18  A synopsis of the chapters in the miniseries is available at   http://jk.globo.com/Series/JK/0,,5071,00.html, 12 November 2006.  It seems to be a signal that one has entered a certain "niche" of the historical pantheon when one's life can be broadcast as fictionalized drama.

 

 

 

 

 

 

AUTHOR


Edward A. “Ted” Riedinger, Professor and Head of Latin American Library at Ohio State University and Adjunct Professor in Departments of History and of Spanish and Portuguese; Adjunct Professor, Center for Latin American Studies, Ohio University, Athens. 
Author of Como se faz um presidente:  A campanha de JK (Nova Fronteira, 1988).  Recent publications:  "Comparative Development of Brazilian Studies in the US and France," Envisioning Brazil (University of Wisconsin Press, 2005) and "Brazilian Studies: Online Resources," College and Research Libraries News (May, 2006).  In preparation: Tropical Domain:  Brazil, The History of an Afro-Mediterranean World in the Southern Atlantic (for 2007) and Renaissance in the Tropics:  Brazilian Culture from the Week of Modern Art, 1922, to the Inauguration of Brasília, 1960 (for 2008).  Holds a master’s in library and information management from the University of California, Berkeley and an MA and PhD in history from the University of Chicago.