|
Bela
Petheo: Images of The Rise of the West
William
McNeill's The Rise of the West is one of the
most important books written on the subject of world history.
When it was published in 1963, reviewers hailed the book
for the new paradigm it advocated—that civilizations
did not develop in isolation but grew as a result of contact
with other civilizations and the exchange of ideas and
techniques that resulted—and in 1964 McNeill was
awarded the National Book Award. As a testimony to the
book’s continued importance, The Rise of the
West continues to sell thousands of copies over 40
years after its publication.
As
part of the preparation of the book, McNeill commissioned
the Hungarian-born artist Bela Petheo to design and draw
a series of illustrations to accompany the text. McNeill
and Petheo collaborated closely on the design of the illustrations,
McNeill's active role in the visual design demonstrating
the value he placed on these images. McNeill himself often
sketched out crude diagrams to clarify his thinking, and
the illustrations in this book were to be a more formal
representation of that processes. Therefore, he did not
view the illustrations as mere supplements to or distractions
from the text, but rather as a vital and necessary part
of the book.
While
McNeill's book has been long admired, Petheo’s images
have been largely forgotten. The same reviewers who praised
the book paid no attention to the illustrations. Indeed,
only one reviewer appears to have taken any notice: in
his New York Times book review, Hugh Trevor-Roper found
the text "learned," "intelligent"
and "stimulating," but dismissed the images
as "trivial and unhelpful."
Textbook
authors and teachers very rarely ask students to look
at or study the graphics that accompany these books with
the same seriousness with which they are asked to examine
the written words, even as education researchers and psychologists
have argued for over two decades that some students learn
better through visual means than through linguistic means.
The visual images in textbooks are rarely composed with
the same attention to compositional style and meaningful
content as the written words. As the critic Alexander
Stille has correctly observed, too many of these "graphics"
in school history textbooks are "distracting, boring
and trivial, cutting down space for a more serious treatment
of events."
Petheo’s
illustrations are quite different; they convey historical
information through word, symbol, gesture and spatial
arrangement. Nearly every mark Petheo committed to paper,
every gradation of shading, every arrangement of symbols
and figures carries information, information necessary
to establish the narrative structure of the whole. All
the marks on the page contribute to the narrative, and
are not present simply to decorate and make eye-catching,
a fault of too many “graphics” today.
A
glance at Petheo’s illustrations would see only
simple drawings, but such a glance would miss the levels
upon levels of historical information contained in these
well-composed, expressive visual narratives. This exhibition
invites the viewer to look deeply at these overlooked
images.
|